Avon Park Florida’s Great Police Debate: To Badge or Not to Badge?

-

In an epic showdown rivaling the fiercest pizza‑versus‑tacos debates, the Avon Park City Council meeting on May 12, 2025 voted 2–2 on whether to even study bringing back its own police department. 

The tie? More tangled than headphone cords in a gym bag.

Having owned a home in Avon Park back in the early 2000's, I am quite familiar with the former PD.

Meet the Vote‑Split Squad

  • For a feasibility study: Councilwomen Berniece Taylor and Michelle “Shelly” Mercure, armed with clipboards and visions of mounted K‑9 units.

  • Against: Mayor Garrett Anderson, who may prefer his city served by Highlands County Sheriff’s Office (HCSO) deputies, and Councilwoman Brittany McGuire, possibly relieved she won’t have to pick out police cruiser paint colors.

  • Absent: Deputy Mayor Jim Barnard—perhaps busy perfecting his “sheriff’s hat” at home.

High‑Level Dreams, High‑Dollar Realities

City Manager Dr. Danielle Kelly rolled out a “very high‐level” plan: hire consultants, hold public forums (popcorn provided!), and survey constituents on what they want in their law enforcement. 

Next up: hire more consultants to “narrow down” those endless options.

But then came the cold tap:

“If that increase stays on that trajectory, you’re looking at well over $4 million” annually for HCSO contract costs alone, Kelly warned—nearly $800 per resident when you count patrol cars and deputy raises.

The Ghost of APPD Past

At this point, former Councilwoman Brenda Gray strolled to the podium for a cameo:

“The reason why the police department was disbanded in 2012 was because there was some corruption…and citizens did not want to go through that,” she recounted.

 Cue the collective gulp.

Deputy Mayor to the Rescue?

Sheriff Paul Blackman—who personally delivers donuts to deputies—clarified that any future HCSO contract hike would tie directly to deputy pay raises.

“If we give our deputies a 5 percent raise—or 10 percent—the increase would be part of the contract,” he said, hands on hips, ready for budget negotiations stronger than a patrol car’s hydraulics.

When Shelly Mercure quipped,

“If we renegotiate and don’t give you the increase, what do we lose?”

Blackman shrugged:

“I’d need to dig into the data to tell you.”

Translation: “Let me consult the spreadsheet of doom.”


Startup Costs: The $8–10M Question

Pastor Moses Anderson—moonlighting as the audience’s question master—pressed on startup costs:

“If we don’t know what it’s going to cost us, why are we discussing it?”

Kelly ventured a wild guess of $8–10 million—a number so imprecise it might double or triple if you toss in bulletproof vests and fancy donut ovens!

DIY Police Department, Courtesy of HCSO

In a twist worthy of a buddy cop movie, Sheriff Blackman offered to skip the pricey study and share HCSO’s own numbers:

“If you want your own police department back, I will help you get it. We’ll do anything we can to help you get there.”

Suddenly, the feasibility study looked as useful as a “kick me” sign on a deputy’s back.

The Bottom Line

After two hours of cost estimates, county‐wide politics, and more acronyms than a texting contest, Avon Park stands pat: no study, no new badges, and more questions than reasons to revive the APPD.

For now, locals can relax under the safety net of 27 HCSO deputies—until next election season, when the entire debate starts again, shinier and budget‑busting as ever.


“No paywall. No puppets. Just local truth. Chip in $3 today” at https://buymeacoffee.com/doublejeopardynews

“Enjoy this content without corporate censorship? Help keep it that way.”

“Ad-Free. Algorithm-Free. 100% Independent. Support now.”


#AvonParkPoliceDebate
#BadgeOrBudget
#StudyTillYouDrop
#SheriffsSolution
#CouncilSplit
#FeasibilityFail
#PolicePotholes
#HCSOHandoff
#BudgetBlunder
#CorruptionCameo
#DonutDiplomacy
#StartupStickerShock
#PolicingPolitics
#MosesAsksWhy
#BrendaSpeaksTruth

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Please Help Find These Forgotten Girls Held at Male Juvenile Prison for Over a Year!

-
Image
  MY MOST IMPORTANT STORY  Dozens of Forgotten Little Girls Held at Male Juvenile Prison for Over a Year! Welcome to the Sunshine State, where the palm trees sway, the alligators lurk, and the legislative process makes Kafka look like a life coach!  Florida House Bill HB21 . Not just a compensation bill but possibly a 20 million dollar "Stay out of Jail Free" card for some folks. This is a bill that does some good—but also trips over its own shoelaces, falls down a staircase, and lands on a historical oversight so big, it might as well have its own zip code! An oversight that overlooks what I consider to be its most vulnerable victims! The Setup: Justice with a Catch HB21 was enacted on July 1, 2024 to compensate victims of abuse from two male juvenile detention facilities located in Florida, Dozier and Okeechobee.  It says, “Hey, survivors of abuse between 1940 and 1975, here’s some compensation for the horrific things you endured!” Sounds good, right? Like a...
Read more

Here's A New HOA Rule Dictating What You Can Do Inside Your Home

-
Image
HOA Overreach: When Your Own Home Isn’t Really Your Own The joys of homeownership—the American dream!  That magical place where you can paint the walls any color you like, blast your music (within reason), and enjoy the simple pleasure of—wait, never mind..... Turns out, your HOA might have something to say about what you do inside your own four walls. Case in point: A longtime homeowner, who has peacefully lived in his residence for 25 years, was blindsided when his HOA suddenly banned smoking inside individual homes.  That’s right—after a quarter-century of no issues, he was informed that lighting up indoors was no longer an option.  The new rule, passed at the HOA’s annual meeting by a majority vote, now restricts smoking to a designated outdoor area. Now, while some might see this as a health-conscious decision, the homeowner—whose wife is a smoker—sees it as an unfair overreach.  In a letter to a local publication, he expressed frustration, writing, “I’ve live...
Read more

Postal Police Stuck Behind ‘Keep Out’ Signs While Mailmen Face Muggers: You Can’t Make This Stuff Up!!

-
Image
As crime against letter carriers surges, one would think that America’s armed, uniformed Postal Police might be hitting the streets to protect our mail.  Instead, they’re still glued to their post office entrances like sentries guarding Fort Frownmore.  Why?  Because since 2020, the Postmaster General decreed they must “protect postal property” only—meaning, they currently serve as glorified lobby bouncers rather than actual roaming guardians of the mailstream. “ They’re robbing letter carriers, they’re sticking a gun in a letter carrier’s face and they’re demanding arrow keys, ” laments Frank Albergo , president of the National Postal Police Union and a Postal Police Officer himself.  An "arrow key" in the context of the Post Office is a specialized, universal key that postal workers use to access various locked mail receptacles, including collection boxes, apartment mailboxes, and cluster boxes. Albergo isn’t exaggerating—research shows over 100 physical assaul...
Read more